—
ABOUT US
Located on beautiful Chautauqua Lake in Mayville, NY, Webb's Captain's Table Restaurant has been family-owned and operated since 1942. Our tradition of friendly hospitality and our dedication to provide a superior customer experience has granted us many acknowledgements from trusted travel resources such as AAA and TripAdvisor.
open year round
open year round
—
AMERICAN FAVORITES
Our extensive menu features an innovative, contemporary selection of American favorites – sizzling, hand-cut steaks and the freshest seafood as well as a variety of vegetarian, gluten-free and heart healthy options.
MenuS
MenuS
An innovative, contemporary selection of American favorites – sizzling, hand-cut steaks and the freshest seafood as well as a variety of vegetarian, gluten-free and heart healthy options.
Served Monday - Saturday from 11:30am - 4pm. (Sunday we serve from our dinner menu all day.)
HOMEMADE SOUPS
FRENCH ONION SOUP
Cup / Bowl
VEGETABLE SOUP
Cup / Bowl
SOUP OF THE DAY
Cup / Bowl
STARTERS
BRUSCHETTA
CAPRESE SALAD
SHRIMP COCKTAIL
3-piece minimum
CRAB CAKE
PAN-SEARED SCALLOPS
VEGETABLE SPRING ROLLS
BUFFALO SHRIMP
FRESH FRIED MOZZARELLA
BONELESS CHICKEN TENDERS
COCONUT SHRIMP
GRILLED FILET SKEWERS
Chicken or Beef
SANDWICHES
FRESH FROM OUR FARM ITALIAN SAUSAGE SANDWICH
Made by hand in-house using pork raised on our own farm, topped with mozzarella and sauteed peppers and onions on a hamburger roll.
CAPTAIN'S BURGER
served with lettuce, tomato and pickle
FRESH FROM OUR FARM GRASS-FED BURGER
served with lettuce, tomato and pickle
GRILLED CHICKEN SANDWICH
served with lettuce, tomato and pickle
+ Bacon
ADDITIONAL TOPPINGS AVAILABLE
+ American or Swiss Cheese
+ Bacon
Blue Cheese
Jalepenos
Mozzarella or Cheddar Cheese
Raw Onion
Sauteed Mushrooms or Onions
CRAB CAKE SANDWICH
Maryland Crab Cake deep-fried on a hearth-baked roll with lettuce, tomato and onion. Wasabi mayonnaise served on the side.
THE BIG CATCH SANDWICH
Icelandic haddock hand breaded, deep-fried, topped with lettuce, tomato, onion and mayonnaise.
GRILLED SALMON SANDWICH
Grilled salmon filet served on a hearth-baked roll with lettuce, tomato and onion. dill sauce served on the side.
TOMATO AND BACON GRILLED CHEESE
Thick sliced Italian bread, grilled with American Cheese, sliced tomatoes and bacon.
BLT WRAP
bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayo wrapped in a garlic herb tortilla
SPICY BLACK BEAN BURGER
Served on a hearth-baked, whole wheat roll with lettuce, tomato, and onion.
BEEF ON WECK
sliced roast beef, drenched in au jus and piled high on a salted kimmelweck roll with horseradish on the side.
STEAK SANDWICH
A 6oz grilled sirloin steak served open-faced on toast.
CAPRESE CHICKEN SANDWICH
Grilled chicken breast with mozzarella, tomato, onion and basil served on a hamburger bun with herb aioli.
CHICKEN CAESAR WRAP
Chicken breast mixed with romaine lettuce, tomato, red onion, parmesan cheese and Webb’s own Caesar dressing
CAJUN RANCH CHICKEN WRAP
Chicken tenders mixed with tomatoes, onion,Cajun ranch, wrapped in a garlic herb tortilla
BUFFALO STYLE CHICKEN WRAP
chicken tenders tossed in a spicy wing sauce and served on a hamburger bun with lettuce, tomato and onion. Served with bleu cheese on the side
TURKEY GRILL
Sliced turkey breast seasoned and roasted, smothered in melted Swiss cheese, bacon and served on grilled Ciabatta bread with a light honey mustard dressing.
FRESH SALADS
STRAWBERRY SALAD
Mixed greens with sliced strawberries, candied pecans, red onions, dry bleu cheese and balsamic vinaigrette.
BLT SALAD
Crisp iceberg lettuce and mixed greens with fresh tomatoes, bacon, egg, bleu cheese, onion, croutons and hot bacon dressing.
CHARBROILED CHICKEN SALAD
A charbroiled chicken breast over crisp greens with tomatoes, eggs, black olives, bacon and choice of dressing.
APPLE SALAD
Mixed greens, iceberg lettuce, topped with sliced apples, dried cranberries, locally grown blueberries, sliced red onions, dry bleu cheese, candied pecans and apple vinaigrette.
GRILLED STEAK SALAD
Grilled sirloin over crisp greens with tomatoes, onions, peppers, bacon, egg and croutons.
JULIENNE SALAD
Julienne-cut ham, turkey, Swiss cheese, American cheese, tomatoes, egg and bacon.
SALMON SALAD MEREDITH
Grilled salmon served over mixed greens with roma tomatoes, toasted almonds and goat cheese.
CAESAR SALAD
Fresh and crisp Romaine lettuce, tossed in Ceasar dressing and topped with croutons and parmesan cheese. ( Available also with Chicken (+6), Shrimp (+10) or Salmon (+10) )
BUFFALO CHICKEN SALAD
Iceberg and mixed greens topped with tomatoes, onions, bleu cheese crumbles, hard boiled egg, bacon and strips of fried chicken breast shaken in buffalo wing sauce. Served with Ranch or bleu cheese dressing on the side.
LUNCH SPECIALS
12.95
SOUP AND SANDWICH
12.95
11.95
1/2 SANDWICH
11.95
11.95
SOUP AND SALAD
11.95
12.95
SALAD AND 1/2 SANDWICH
12.95
13.95
SALAD AND SANDWICH
13.95
SERVED NIGHTLY from 4pm - 9pm. SERVED ALL DAY on Sunday.
HOMEMADE SOUPS
FRENCH ONION SOUP
Cup / Bowl
VEGETABLE SOUP
Cup / Bowl
SOUP OF THE DAY
Cup / Bowl
STARTERS
BRUSCHETTA
CAPRESE SALAD
SHRIMP COCKTAIL
3-piece minimum
CRAB CAKE
PAN-SEARED SCALLOPS
VEGETABLE SPRING ROLLS
BUFFALO SHRIMP
FRESH FRIED MOZZARELLA
BONELESS CHICKEN TENDERS
Buffalo style, butter-garlic or cajun
COCONUT SHRIMP
GRILLED FILET SKEWERS
Served with chipotle barbecue sauce
SALADS
-
CAESAR SALAD
Fresh and crisp Romaine lettuce, tossed in Ceasar dressing and topped with croutons and parmesan cheese.
-
Add Chicken
Add Shrimp
Add Salmon
CHARBROILED CHICKEN SALAD
A charbroiled chicken breast over crisp greens with tomatoes, eggs, black olives, bacon and choice of dressing
JULIENNE SALAD
Julienne cut ham, turkey, Swiss cheese, American cheese, assorted vegetables, egg and bacon
SALMON SALAD MEREDITH
Grilled salmon filet served over mixed greens, topped with roma tomatoes, toasted almonds and goat cheese
CHICKEN
MARINATED CHICKEN BREAST
Our tender boneless breast of chicken marinated to perfection in our special herbs and then charbroiled
CHICKEN CHAUTAUQUA
Our tender boneless breast of chicken lightly breaded and pan sautéed and topped with fresh mushroom caps, bacon strips and poulee sauce
CHICKEN ROSA
Our tender boneless breast of chicken, dusted with flour, pan sautéed, layered with mozzarella cheese, artichoke hearts, roasted red peppers, ham, and capers, topped with Piccata sauce
CHICKEN MEDITERRANEAN
Grilled chicken topped with goat cheese, sun-dried tomatoes, basil, black olives, roasted red peppers, capers and a lemon butter wine sauce served over linguini.
CHICKEN PICATTA
Our tender boneless breast of chicken, dusted in flour and pan sautéed, topped with a lemon-butter white wine sauce, capers, sun-dried tomatoes, sautéed mushrooms, black olives, artichoke hearts. Served over linguini
SMOTHERED CHICKEN
Our tender boneless breast of chicken, topped with mushrooms, onions, green peppers and Colby-Jack cheese
CHICKEN OSCAR (WEBB’S STYLE)
Our tender boneless breast of chicken, lightly breaded and pan sautéed, then topped with shrimp, asparagus and Hollandaise sauce
BEEF
PRIME RIB
Sailor’s Cut - 8oz; Mate’s Cut - 12oz; Captain’s Cut - 20oz
NEW YORK STRIP
Mate’s Cut - 12 oz; Captain’s Cut - 20oz
RIB EYE
Mate’s Cut - 12 oz; Captain’s Cut - 20oz
FILET MIGNON
Mate’s Cut - 6 oz; Captain’s Cut - 10 oz
SURF & TURF
6 oz. Filet Mignon with 2 Lobster Tails
VEAL
VEAL CHAUTAUQUA
Milk-fed veal, lightly breaded and pan sautéed, topped with fresh mushroom caps, bacon strips and poulet sauce
VEAL OSCAR (WEBB’S STYLE)
Milk-fed veal, lightly breaded and pan sautéed, topped with shrimp, asparagus and Hollandaise sauce
VEAL PICCATA
Milk-fed veal, dusted with flour and pan sautéed, topped with a lemon-butter white wine sauce, capers, sun-dried tomatoes, sautéed mushrooms, black olives, artichoke hearts, served over linguini
VEAL PARMESAN
Milk-fed veal, lightly breaded and pan sautéed, then topped with mozzarella cheese and our own marinara sauce. Served with a side of linguini
PASTA
OUR OWN HERB GARDEN PASTA
Linguini topped with pomodoro sauce (diced tomatoes, onions, garlic, basil, virgin olive oil), Reggiano Parmesano cheese and melted mozzarella cheese
CHICKEN PARMESAN
A boneless breast of chicken, lightly breaded and pan sautéed, topped with melted mozzarella cheese and our own marinara sauce. Served with a side of linguini
LINGUINI WITH MARINARA SAUCE
Linguini served with our homemade marinara sauce
LINGUINI WITH MEATBALLS
Linguini served with our homemade marinara sauce and a homemade meatball
SEAFOOD
SHRIMP SCAMPI (WEBB’S STYLE)
Tender Gulf Shrimp, broiled with fresh mushrooms in a lemon garlic butter sauce, and topped with fresh bread crumbs. Served over linguini.
HORSERADISH CRUSTED SALMON
Salmon filet topped with horseradish and breadcrumbs. Served with horseradish cream sauce and roasted red pepper coulis sauce.
PAN FRIED WALLEYE
Canadian Lake Erie walleye, breaded, pan-fried, served with lemon and tartar sauce.
SEAFOOD JULIENNE
Tender, delicate lobster, scallops, and shrimp, broiled in a light garlic butter sauce with seasoned bread crumbs and mushrooms.
BROILED SEA SCALLOPS
Au Gratin, Cajun or hand breaded and deep fried.
BROILED GULF SHRIMP
Au Gratin, Cajun or hand breaded and deep fried.
SUSTAINABLE CANADIAN SALMON FILET
Grilled, Blackened or Broiled with white wine
FISHERMAN’S PLATTER
(Broiled or Fried) Broiled lobster dainty, stuffed devil crab, scallops, shrimp and white fish.
BROILED GULF SHRIMP AND SEA SCALLOPS
Au gratin or Cajun
BROILED LOBSTER TAIL
Two 4 oz. Tails; Four 4 oz. Tails
PORK
PORK CHAUTAUQUA
8 oz Pork cutlet lightly breaded and pan sauteéd, topped with fresh mushroom caps, bacon strips and poulee sauce.
PORK SIRLOIN STEAKS
A pair of grilled boneless pork loin steaks served with a mushroom peppercorn sauce.
WEEKEND DINNER SPECIALS
(FRI) FRESH FISH OF THE DAY
Market price
(FRI) FISH & CHIPS
Icelandic haddock deep fried or broiled.
(SAT) 6OZ FILET ROYALE
Bacon wrapped filet topped with melted blue cheese, caramelized onions, and bourbon peppercorn sauce.
SUNDAY SPECIALS
SUNDAY FULL DINNERS INCLUDE: SOUP, SALAD, VEGETABLE AND YOUR CHOICE OF PIE, ICE CREAM OR SHERBET
WEBB'S FAMOUS BAKED CHICKEN
A la carte includes: mashed potatoes, gravy, green beans, biscuits, stuffing and cranberry sauce. Full dinners include: also include soup, salad and choice of pie, ice cream or sherbet. served family style
HAM STEAK
8 OZ PRIME RIB
SERVED DAILY from 11:30am - 9pm
SNACKS & APPETIZERS
COCONUT SHRIMP
SHRIMP COCKTAIL
3 piece minimum
DEEP FRIED PICKLES
JALAPENO POPPERS
- with spinach & artichoke dip
TORTILLA CHIPS
- with salsa
- with spinach & artichoke dip
HUMMUS
served with fried pita chips, carrots and celery
ONION RINGS
BONELESS CHICKEN TENDERS
Buffaloi style, butter-garlic or Cajun
CHICKEN FINGERS
served with French fries
PIZZA LOGS
served with French fries
***
TAPAS
A TRADITION OF TASTING AND SHARING A VARIETY OF APPETIZER-SIDE DISHES
BUFFALO SHRIMP
hand breaded to order
GRILLED FILET SKEWERS
served with a spicy chipotle pepper barbecue sauce.
CRAB CAKE
House-made lump crab cake sautéed and served with a lemon aioli sauce.
PAN-SEARED SCALLOPS
with balsamic reduction
VEGETABLE SPRING ROLLS
Carrots, cabbage, sprouts, bamboo chutes, egg roll wrap. Served with orange ginger sauce.
BRUSCHETTA
Grilled ciabatta bread topped with diced tomatoes, onions, basil, garlic and olive oil.
FRESH FRIED MOZZARELLA
Thick slice of breaded mozzarella cheese, served with homemade marinara sauce.
SANDWICHES
SERVED WITH CHOICE OF: FRENCH FRIES, CHIPS, COTTAGE CHEESE, POTATO SALAD, APPLESAUCE, COLESLAW, FRESH FRUIT +1, ONION RINGS +1, SWEET POTATO FRIES +1
CAPTAIN'S BURGER
served with lettuce, tomato and pickle
FRESH FROM OUR FARM GRASS-FED BURGER
served with lettuce, tomato and pickle
GRILLED CHICKEN SANDWICH
served with lettuce, tomato and pickle
+ Bacon
ADDITIONAL TOPPINGS AVAILABLE
+ American or Swiss Cheese
+ Bacon
Blue Cheese
Jalepenos
Mozzarella or Cheddar Cheese
Raw Onion
Sauteed Mushrooms or Onions
FRESH FROM OUR FARM ITALIAN SAUSAGE SANDWICH
Made by hand, in-house using pork raised on our own farm, topped with melted mozzarella, sautéed peppers and onions on a hamburger roll.
SPICY BLACK BEAN BURGER
Served on a hearth-baked, whole wheat roll with lettuce, tomato, and onion.
SIRLOIN STEAK SANDWICH
A 6oz grilled sirloin steak served open-faced on toast.
GRILLED SALMON SANDWICH
Grilled salmon filet served on a hearth-baked roll with lettuce, tomato and onion. dill sauce served on the side.
CRAB CAKE SANDWICH
Maryland Crab Cake deep-fried on a hearth-baked roll with lettuce, tomato and onion. Wasabi mayonnaise served on the side.
THE BIG CATCH SANDWICH
Icelandic haddock hand breaded, deep-fried, topped with lettuce, tomato, onion and mayonnaise.
CHICKEN CAESAR WRAP
Chicken breast mixed with romaine lettuce, tomato, red onion, parmesan cheese and Webb’s own Caesar dressing
BLT WRAP
bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayo wrapped in a garlic herb tortilla
CAPRESE CHICKEN SANDWICH
Grilled chicken breast with mozzarella, tomato, onion and basil, served on a hamburger bun with herb aioli.
SALADS
SERVED WITH ROLLS AND BUTTER
GRILLED STEAK SALAD
Grilled sirloin over crisp greens with tomatoes, onions, peppers, bacon, egg and croutons.
CHARBROILED CHICKEN SALAD
Charbroiled chicken breast over crisp greens with tomatoes, eggs, black olives and bacon.
JULIENNE SALAD
Julienne-cut ham, turkey, Swiss cheese, American cheese, assorted vegetables, egg and bacon.
BLT SALAD
Crisp iceberg lettuce and mixed greens, fresh tomato, bacon, egg, bleu cheese, onion, croutons, hot bacon dressing.
SALMON SALAD MEREDITH
Grilled salmon served over mixed greens with Roma tomatoes, toasted almonds and goat cheese.
STRAWBERRY SALAD
Mixed greens, strawberries, candied pecans, red onions, dry bleu cheese, balsamic vinaigrette.
CAESAR SALAD
GRILLED SHRIMP CAESAR
GRILLED CHICKEN CAESAR
GRILLED SALMON CAESAR
We offer the following items for Children 10 and Under
CHILDREN'S MENU
GRILLED CHEESE SANDWICH
served with french fries
HAMBURGER
served with french fries
CHEESEBURGER
served with french fries
CHICKEN FINGERS
(4) served with french fries
PIZZA FINGERS
(3) served with french fries
GRILLED CHICKEN SANDWICH
lettuce, tomato, mayo served with french fries
SHRIMP BASKET
served with french fries
NY STRIP STEAK
(6oz) served with french fries and a side salad
SPAGHETTI & MEATBALLS
served with a side salad
—
—
—
SIMPLE ELEGANCE
Whether your are gathering for a family dinner, enjoying cocktails with colleagues or savoring the moment with friends, we are dedicated to providing a welcoming atmosphere or relaxation and refinement. Our attention to detail, paired with a tradition of friendly hospitality ensures you will have a positive and memorable dining experience.
